Paul Schrader is a filmmaker that understands, at an almost virtuousic level, how to communicate his ideas with both images and the words paired with them. The Card Counter, his long awaited follow up to 2018’s First Reformed, is a deeply tense and well refined film about how people go on with themselves after committing horrific acts. It also highlights the importance of connection between people and the danger of isolation in the wake of such events. With Oscar Isaac and Tiffany Haddish each giving performances that carry great emotional poignancy, Schrader’s film is a dramatic tour de force which will sit with audiences for a long time yet.
Isaac stars as William Tell, a former US Army interrogator who now makes a living as a professional gambler drifting from one casino to the next. At the outset of the film, he is drawn in by two people with very different intentions. First, he is offered the chance to make real money with the financial backing of a benefactor, represented by Haddish’s La Linda. The other is a young man, Cirk (played by Tye Sheridan) who seeks to enlist Tell in a revenge plot against the man who trained both his father and the gambler in torture, but who escaped prosecution for war crimes. The three characters go from table to table making money as Tell does his best to steer Cirk away from his violent intentions, all of which sets the stage for a climax that manages to shock as well as underscore the philosophical leanings of the script.
There are certain tropes that Schrader seems to depend on in this film and others, like First Reformed and his most well renowned script, Taxi Driver. Tell’s journal and narration is central to the storytelling, which makes the film less subtle than it could be. Though it does seem jarring in certain moments, overall the script is tight and creates a knife’s edge feeling of tension all throughout. The writer-director’s aesthetic composition is astounding in certain scenes, complimented by the stillness of Alexander Dynan’s cinematography. There is also a crane shot from a high angle that absolutely deserves to be remembered as one of the finer moments in film photography of the last few years. Between these elements and a unique combination of score and original songs by Robert Levon Breen and Giancarlo Vulcano, The Card Counter is a striking example of viscerally commanding cinema.
The acting is impeccable across the board. Oscar Isaac turns in a performance so steely and mesmerising that it’s almost an effort to focus your attention anywhere else. Tiffany Haddish excels in a dramatic role, having established herself in comedy up till now. Her natural delivery and flair suit the film exceedingly well. Sheridan is also quite good. His performance is a combination of wayward youth and sociopathic calm. Willem Dafoe also does well in the smaller part of the career military man and enhanced interrogation aficionado.
The Card Counter goes wide in moments, with the use of certain conventions and inconsistency in a tonal sense. These issues are minor, however, and Schrader’s film remains an incisive and brutal meditation on it’s chosen subject matter, with a fairly direct preoccupation with the notion of American Imperialism and Exceptionalism in the context of war. Wrapping itself up at the right length and with a moment that manages to devastate emotionally, the latest from this iconic director is a film that will be revered as yet another classic in his oeuvre.
4/5